So with my old friend Matt in town from NYC, we wanted to show him the New Haven drinking attractions last night. Perfectly pleasant, on the whole, but I feel the need to mention our stop at Rudy's. It was the low point of the evening.
First, a little background. On the increasingly rare occasion that I want to imbibe my Adult Beverages out in the world with strangers, I really, really like divey, shitty bars. They're not scene-y, there is zero pretension, and everyone that is there is there for one reason: they want to get solidly ham-faced on a selection of drinks they may not have at home. There's no dress code, there's no disgusting "pick-up" vibe, and there is little chance you will even have to speak to anyone other than a friendly smile and nod at the bartender. It's remarkably easy to find these bars. Look for a vaguely Irish name, or no name at all. A hot tray of old boiled potatoes in the back is definitely a good sign. If there's a velvet rope, you can't get in with your sneakers on, or there are groups of more than four gigantic, tan, oily dudes in jewelry and tiny t-shirts standing around looking for someone to date-rape, you are in the wrong place.
With that said, I must also admit that I was never HUGELY into Rudy's in the first place. Though it seems, on the surface, to be a bar that would fit the above criteria, something always just struck me as kind of off about the place. On my way back from the liquor store just now, I tried to hammer out what these pre-existing problems were.
1. The Carved-Up Tables and Graffitied Bathroom: I know, I know, we're trying to establish a certain vibe here. And in a way, these things do. But there are only so many times I can read "Jeremy Loves it in the Ass" in black magic marker before I am kinda bored with the whole thing. Big points to the old photographs on the walls, though.
2. The Groups of Nouveau-Punk Kids: A long running frustration, and possibly not the fault of the bar. Punk erupted out of a time and place that has absolutely no resemblance to downtown New Haven. Punk was born out of working class hellholes in England. All the pyramid studs and liberty spikes in the world are not going to change the fact that you're in the middle of the Yale Campus, you grew up in Danbury, and your parents are doctors. Please, find a new way to express your dark inner yearnings and be as offensive as possible to strangers. Oh, and sometimes you play music at Rudy's? Nope, that's another strike.
3. The Very Notion of "Frites:" Oh, I'm sorry, are we in Belgium? You can put mayonnaise on fries all you want. Hell, I do, myself. But they're still fries. In this case, pretty damned good fries, but enough already. I feel about as warmly about "frites" as I did about the whole "Freedom Fries" thing that rednecks seemed to be so into for a while there.
With that said, let's think about the good things about Rudy's, as they existed prior to last night:
1. Not Being Picked Up On, or Being Able to Pull Anyway: No nonsense here. Just good old-fashioned drinking, with a wide, cheap selection on tap.
2. Conscientious Bathroom Lines: Everyone has to go, and everyone moves it along. No extended make-out or coke-blowing sessions holding this line up.
3. Reasonable Crowd: Little pretension, except for the whole "Not-Pretentious-as-Pretension" folks, which are at least somewhat easier to deal with.
4. Buying beer at 20: There's always that.
Good enough to warrant a few quick pints, yeah? Not anymore. Rudy's is now officially guilty of being the only thing WORSE than a pick-up joint, and that's being one and pretending not to be. Last night found me slammed in the middle of 150 dudes, all freshly showered, wearing repellant cologne, and looking up the skirt of all three of the women there, most of whom had faces like potatoes. The back room, usually a safe haven on even the worst nights, was full of people playing pool badly, high-fiving a LOT, and drinking shots of Jagermeister combatively. The beer was particularly bad, and tasted as though it had been poured hours before.
There was no place to sit, everyone was there to BE there, take pictures of each other, and sleep with someone. The whole thing made me feel kind of awful. What was once a little neighborhood bar of already questionable appeal, now is in line with the likes of Alchemy (Don't miss "Hooters Night" tonight!), Van Dome (Foam Party Wednesdays with DJ Skribble!), or Gotham Citi (Rohypnol Tuesdays!). We had one beer and left immediately, and probably won't be returning, now that I can drink with grownups. Or better still, at my desk by myself.